Text size

Theme

Language

"Paraffin oil used in hospitals for lubricating instruments and wound healing"

About: Fiona Stanley Hospital / General Outpatient Clinics

(as the patient),

I went to hospital recently to have a small lump removed from the top of my head. There was a graft taken from my leg to cover my scalp where the lump was removed.

After the operation I returned to the out patient clinic of the hospital. They said a small part of the graft hadn't taken so I heard them talking about using paraffin oil to create a moist area to help the graft heal.

After two more tries at doing this ( Silver Chain nurses ) they said that it still wasn't right and there was secretion of a fluid in the area.

Now they said they needed to reverse this and use something to dry up the area to try to get it to heal.

When I first heard them talk about paraffin I just accepted that they knew what they were doing. I understand Fiona Stanley is a quite new hospital south of Perth.

Since then I have had the uneasy feeling that I might have been wrong to have blind faith in their decisions. Surely I believe they must have been following a set protocol.

I started looking more into paraffin which is a byproduct of petroleum sludge and is a hydrocarbon.

From internet  "Paraffin wax is created as a byproduct of petroleum sludge, treated with carcinogenic chemicals and even after processing it still contains up to 11 toxic compounds and chemicals. Two of those toxic substances are benzene and toluene."

From other sites I have read they talk about cancers these toxic compounds can cause and especially brain problems. I believe this was happening on the crown of my head.

The hospital actually gave me a small 5g tube of "White Soft Paraffin" that I can rub on the wound at a later date. The paraffin comes from Perrigo Australia that used to be Orion Laboratories. I have tried to talk to Perrigo and there is no answer from both an 1800 number and a local number in Perth.

Obviously it seems is just a distribution centre although you would think the phones would have been manned in early afternoon on a week day.

So why did they try this, in my opinion, dubious paraffin oil rather than any of the fine essential oils that have been used by humanity for thousands of years?

I think because the paraffin oil is stated to be sterile and it is branded as such on the tube I have. I think they are probably cheap and sourced from a global supplier who supplies many countries around the world.

I would have liked a bit more disclosure from the hospital that they have opted for a hydrocarbon product to soak into my scalp and they could have discussed the risks.

Then I would have been within my rights to refuse the possibly toxic product and I could have used Savlon cream which has served me well for more than 60 years.

Does Perrigo or the hospitals they supply analyse these products for toxic substances or traces thereof?  Really, I believe, every batch should have some certificate shipped with the product clearly indicating any traces of toxins and exactly what the product contains.

I believe that Fiona Stanley the person would be alarmed if she knew.

Do you have a similar story to tell? Tell your story & make a difference ››

Responses

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 6 months ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 15/10/2024 at 2:46 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia at 3:54 PM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear whispersh54,

Thank you for your care opinion post regarding the use of Paraffin Emollient for wound healing in WA Health. Your post was interesting and following, I did some investigations myself.

I am truly sorry that your concerns about the use of Paraffin were not addressed with you at the time of your treatment. Paraffin Emollient is used to assist with wound healing, most commonly used in Plastic Reconstructive Surgery with the intention of hydrating the dry wounds or removing scabs without causing trauma. Similarly, Paraffin impregnated wound dressings are also used for graft care post operation to keep the area moist and hydrated. The reason being that the newly healed grafts do not have sweat and oil glands as in original skin causing them to dry out and flake.

All dressing products used in WA health are guided by the WA Health tender contract, which requires companies to provide Therapeutic Goods Association (TGA) certification. In addition, internally here at Fiona Stanley Fremantle Hospitals group we also have a Product Evaluation and Standardisation Committee (PESC), which approves trial and use of medications and dressings. Products that do not have TGA certification or are rejected by our PESC are not permitted for use. This gives me confidence that the medications and dressings used here are not harmful.

I wish you well in your continued recovery.

Regards,

Neil Doverty

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by whispersh54 (the patient)

Yes there is a set protocol for wound healing which is supported by the TGA. We can agree on that point.

Although, I understand there is still the fact that waste products recycled from petroleum production can contain Toluene and Benzene. This is also a fact which can't be denied.

All I am saying is I believe there should be disclosure to patients informing them that there is the potential for cancers from these toxic carcinogens.

I feel that surely alternatives could be explored which could be sourced from essential oils which could have a better outcome. Heaven forbid us to ever question organisations like the TGA.

I would think executive health professionals have patient care support at the forefront of their minds.

Thanks for reading and giving feedback

Response from Neil Doverty, Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group, South Metropolitan Health Service 6 months ago
Neil Doverty
Executive Director Fiona Stanley and Fremantle Hospitals Group,
South Metropolitan Health Service
Submitted on 18/10/2024 at 2:37 PM
Published on Care Opinion Australia at 4:09 PM


picture of Neil Doverty

Dear whispersh54,

I’m sorry you still feel uneasy about the use of Paraffin Oil.

I’d like to share some information from the Regulatory Toxicology and Pharmacology Journal (volume 132, July 2022) which may help to provide you with reassurance that our hospital and health service does not use carcinogenic products on our patients:

“The carcinogenicity of unrefined mineral oil is related to its polycyclic aromatic compounds (PAC) content. Refining operations focus on the removal of PAC. After several refining steps, the potentially hazardous PAC are removed to meet safety thresholds, assuring that the refined mineral oil is non-carcinogenic” (Carrillo et al., 2022).

This applies to both the Paraffin Oil we use, as well as the Savlon you refer to, which also contains Paraffin Oil.

May I trust that this is reassuring for you?

Regards,

Neil Doverty

  • {{helpful}} {{helpful == 1 ? "person thinks" : "people think"}} this response is helpful

Update posted by whispersh54 (the patient)

Thank you and I feel more reassured although this would obviously depend on what the threshold was and if that totally eliminated risk. Also whether different batches ever exceeded that threshold.

Unfortunately we live in a toxic world and it isn't just hospital treatments because plastics also have potential toxins. These toxins could build up and they might not be easy to detect or remove from our bodies.

This is something that science should be continually researching to eradicate these forever toxins. There are so many wonderful natural healthy products in our environment which don't come from petroleum waste products.

The world I dream of doesn't make everything we use from petroleum waste and this is for our children and grandchildren. It is a legacy which we shouldn't be burdening them with.

Thanks for reading and comments

Opinions
Next Response j
Previous Response k